
A bottom seal machine does one thing thousands of times a shift: feed film, close a hot bar, hold, cut, stack. The motor choice decides how repeatable those five steps are. Stepper motors are cheap, simple and adequate on a 60 pcs/min line running one bag size. They become the bottleneck the moment a buyer asks for 200 pcs/min on printed film with a length tolerance of half a millimetre.
This is not a brand argument. It is a torque-and-feedback argument, and it plays out differently on every axis of the machine.
A bottom seal machine is not one drive. It is a set of axes, and they do not share the same requirements:
● Unwind and tension — holds the roll back. Low dynamics, tolerant of small position error, so stepper control is still common here.
● Main feed and pull-out belts — index the film one bag length per cycle. Length accuracy lives or dies on this axis.
● Sealing bar or hot knife — must travel, press, dwell and retract inside a fixed window. Dwell repeatability sets seal strength.
● Cutting knife — fixed blade on simple machines, flying knife on high-output models where the film never stops.
● Auxiliary — gusset folding, punch, perforation, stacking. Short moves, low mass, low precision demand.
Our bottom seal bag making machine series puts servo on feed, sealing and knife axes while keeping stepper or inverter control on unwind, which is the split most buyers end up with once the speed target is fixed.
A hybrid stepper delivers its rated holding torque at standstill and loses it as step rate climbs, because current cannot build in the winding fast enough. A 1.8 degree motor holding 3 N·m at rest may give well under half of that at the pulse rate a fast sealing axis needs. A servo motor holds rated torque to its base speed, then runs at constant power, and tolerates a short overload of two to three times rated torque during acceleration.
Two consequences matter on a sealing axis:
● Resonance — steppers have mid-band resonance where available torque dips. On a sealing bar this reads as a hesitation before contact, which often shows on the finished bag as a slightly wider or glossier seal at one end.
● Acceleration budget — the bar must reach the film and stop without bounce. Servo settles faster with less overshoot, so the dwell window stays where the recipe put it.
A stepper is open loop. The controller sends pulses and assumes the rotor followed. When film tension spikes, a bearing tightens or the roll has a thick splice, the rotor can slip a few steps and nothing reports it. The error is silent, and because it repeats, bag length can walk away from the setpoint over a shift instead of failing at once.
Servo closes the loop with an encoder, typically 17-bit or 23-bit, so position error becomes an alarm rather than a scrap pile. On a flying knife machine this is not a luxury: knife and film must stay phase-locked while both are moving, and only closed-loop control holds that relationship as film speed changes.
● Symptom to watch — bags that measure correctly at start-up and drift 1 to 2 mm after two hours usually point at an open-loop feed losing steps, not at a worn blade.
The CW-1400FB flying knife bottom sealing machine is built around that constraint. It cuts on the fly across a 200 to 3,000 mm bag length range and offers double servo feeding because printed film needs two independently corrected lanes.
Seal strength is a function of temperature, pressure and time under pressure. Temperature is held by the thermocouple to a few degrees. Pressure is mechanical. Time is where the drive shows up.
If the sealing bar’s approach varies 20 ms between cycles, effective dwell varies 20 ms. On a 120 ms dwell that is a 17 percent swing in sealing time. Thin LDPE tolerates it. A 90 micron metallised laminate sealed near the edge of its window does not, and the failure surfaces downstream as a leak at the bottom fold rather than at the seal itself.
● Servo — position and velocity loops repeat the approach profile to within a few encoder counts, so dwell is set by the recipe, not by load.
● Stepper — approach time depends on how much torque the axis needed that cycle, so dwell shifts with film stiffness and roll diameter.
Take a real configuration. A five-lane high-speed bottom sealing machine running 1,000 bags per minute is executing 200 cycles per minute, because five bags come off each stroke. That is one cycle every 300 ms.
Inside those 300 ms the machine must index the film one bag length, close the bar, dwell long enough to fuse the sealant, open, cut and transfer. If the seal needs 120 ms of dwell, roughly 180 ms remains for everything else, including acceleration and deceleration of every axis involved.
● At 60 pcs/min — a 1,000 ms cycle. A stepper ramping for 150 ms is invisible.
● At 150 pcs/min — a 400 ms cycle. Ramp time starts competing with dwell.
● At 200 pcs/min and above — under 300 ms. Ramp time is the cycle, and stepper torque at that pulse rate can no longer reach position without overshoot.
This is why the CW-1100BS5 high speed bottom sealing machine runs Yaskawa servo and inverter with five lanes, inline hot slitting and block seal. At 1,000 pcs/min there is no time budget left to absorb an open-loop ramp.
A servo axis costs more than a stepper axis: motor, encoder, drive and commissioning time. The gap narrows once you count what the cheaper axis consumes.
● Scrap — length drift and seal rejects are film, ink, labour and machine hours already spent.
● Stops — open-loop faults are found by inspection, while a servo drive reports the fault code and the axis.
● Speed ceiling — a machine that cannot pass 120 pcs/min caps the revenue of the line behind it, and no later retrofit returns that lost year.
● Retrofit cost — converting an axis later means motor mounts, cabinet space, wiring and recommissioning, which usually costs more than specifying servo at order.
Match the drive to the cycle time, not the catalogue.
Send us bag size, film structure and target output. Our engineers will confirm which axes need servo, how many, and the realistic speed before you compare quotations.
Get a Drive Specification Review
Stepper is not obsolete, and a supplier who insists on servo everywhere is not listening to the brief.
● Low speed, single format — 40 to 80 pcs/min with one bag size and stable film. The tolerance a stepper holds is inside what that customer accepts.
● Auxiliary axes — unwind tension, gusset folding, punch indexing. Short light moves where closed loop adds cost without adding capability.
● Simple sites — fewer electronics in the cabinet, simpler spares, and a local technician can swap a driver without a tuning laptop.
● First machine on a tight budget — a stepper machine that runs reliably at 70 pcs/min beats a servo machine that was under-specified to fit the price.
Read the axis list of a well-specified bottom seal machine and you rarely find one technology. You find servo where timing and position are paid for, and stepper or inverter where they are not.
The CW-1000PR+C2 bag-on-roll bottom sealing machine uses four servo motors, and its sealing principle swings rather than stopping the film, so the drive never pays an acceleration penalty for a stationary seal. Bag length runs 150 to 2,000 mm at 230 pcs/min, with line speed up to 110 m/min without core.
● Axes that need servo — main feed, sealing bar, flying knife, perforation, registration correction.
● Axes that do not — unwind, auxiliary nip, stacking table, fan and pump loads.
Do not accept the words servo motor as a specification. Ask for the axis list, then test it.
● Axis list — every axis, its motor type, rated torque, encoder resolution, and whether the drive is pulse or fieldbus controlled.
● Brand and spares — Yaskawa, Delta, Inovance, Schneider and Panasonic carry different lead times by market, so ask what is stocked locally.
● Dwell window — the sealing time range the recipe can hold at rated speed, in milliseconds, not the word adjustable.
● Witnessed run — 30 minutes at rated speed on your own film, measuring bag length every 50 bags and seal strength at the start, middle and end.
● Fault log — ask to see the alarm history of a machine already running in the field, not a demo unit.
No. Below roughly 80 pcs/min with one bag format, a stepper holds the tolerance the market accepts at a lower price. Servo earns its cost when cycle time drops under 400 ms, when printed film demands registration correction, or when a flying knife must stay phase-locked with the film.
Three is the practical minimum for a fast machine: main feed, sealing bar and cutting knife. Bag-on-roll and perforating models add winding and perforation, which is why four servos is common on that family. Everything else can stay stepper or inverter driven.
Mechanically yes, commercially rarely. Motor mounts, cabinet space, drive wiring and recommissioning usually cost more than specifying servo at order, and the frame and knife may still limit the achievable speed. Treat retrofit as a fix for one problem axis, not as a speed upgrade.
On a stepper-driven feed this is almost always lost steps: a tension spike, a tight bearing or a film splice makes the rotor slip, and the error accumulates silently. Check film tension and the pull-out belt nip first, then verify whether the axis holds position with a dial indicator over 200 cycles.
Not much. Servo motors have no brushes, run cooler at standstill than a stepper holding full current, and report faults instead of failing quietly. The real cost difference is the drive price and the need for a technician who can tune gains, so ask what local support exists before ordering.
Above about 150 pcs/min cycle time falls under 400 ms and ramp time starts eating the dwell window. Below 80 pcs/min a stepper is defensible. Between those figures the decision depends on film structure, print registration and how tight the customer’s length tolerance is.
Still deciding between servo and stepper?
Tell us the bag, the film and the shift target. We will map each axis to a drive type and send a configuration you can compare line by line.
Request an Axis-by-Axis Proposal
● How To Solve Uneven Cutting Problems In Bottom Sealing Machine — the mechanical causes behind a symptom that looks electrical.
● How To Calculate The Production Capacity Of A Bottom Sealing Machine — turn rated speed into a shift figure you can quote to a customer.
● Coming next: Flying Knife vs Fixed Blade on Bottom Seal Machines, and How to Read a Bag Making Machine Drive Cabinet (With Photos).