
HDPE, LDPE and LLDPE are all polyethylene. On a heavy duty bag making machine they behave like three different materials, because they are: one is linear and stiff, one is branched and soft, one is linear with just enough branching to be tough. The machine does not care about the chemistry, only about what happens at the sealing bar and in the nip.
Buyers who switch resin to save cost, or who accept whatever film the local blown film line produces, often find that bag quality changes without a single machine setting being touched. This article explains why, and what to change when you switch.
Density and branching explain almost every processing difference:
● HDPE (high density) — linear chains, minimal branching, density around 0.94 to 0.96 g/cm³. Stiff, strong in tension, low in tear resistance across the machine direction. Films are thin and crackle.
● LDPE (low density) — long-chain branched, density 0.91 to 0.93 g/cm³. Soft, easy to seal, forgiving, relatively low strength per micron.
● LLDPE (linear low density) — linear with short-chain branching, density 0.915 to 0.94 g/cm³. Higher puncture and tear resistance than LDPE at the same density, but stiffer and harder to process on older extruders.
On a heavy duty bag, the resin choice sets the achievable strength at a given thickness, and therefore the thickness you need to hit a load specification. That is the commercial decision hiding behind the technical one.
Seal behaviour is where most production problems appear:
● LDPE — widest sealing window, lowest seal initiation temperature, typically 120 to 160 °C on the bar depending on thickness. It tolerates operator variation and slow machines.
● LLDPE — higher melting point, needs roughly 10 to 20 °C more than LDPE, and the seal needs slightly more dwell to develop full strength. Modern metallocene grades seal better than older ones.
● HDPE — highest seal initiation temperature and the narrowest window, often 150 to 180 °C. HDPE film also shrinks at seal temperature, so the seal area can curl and the bag can distort.
Two practical consequences. First, a machine set up for LDPE will run HDPE with more scrap unless temperature and dwell are re-profiled. Second, a heavy duty bag made from HDPE needs a wider seal or a thicker sealant layer to reach the same strength as LDPE, because the seal itself is the weak point.
The CW-800FBA heavy duty bottom sealing machine uses heating wire sealing and is specified for thick film up to 0.25 mm, which is the range where these differences become visible rather than theoretical.
Mechanical behaviour decides which resin suits which bag:
● Stiffness — HDPE is the stiffest, which is why it dominates T-shirt carrier bags and thin liners. Stiffness helps a bag stand open for packing and hurts drop performance.
● Puncture resistance — LLDPE wins clearly. For bags holding sharp-edged content, rubble or frozen goods, LLDPE or a blend is the practical choice.
● Tear resistance — LDPE has good balanced tear; HDPE tears easily along the machine direction, which is why an HDPE bag that snags tends to split rather than stretch.
● Load at break — at equal thickness, HDPE gives higher tensile strength in the machine direction, LLDPE gives better dart impact, LDPE sits between them.
For a heavy duty bag carrying 10 to 25 kg, the usual answer is a blend: LLDPE for toughness with a proportion of HDPE for stiffness, or a coextruded structure with different layers doing different jobs.
When you change resin, change these five settings — in this order:
● Sealing temperature — start 10 °C below the previous setting for a softer resin, 10 to 20 °C above for a harder one, then adjust by peel test.
● Dwell time — HDPE and thicker films need more dwell; LDPE can run shorter. On a fixed-cycle machine, dwell is set by the cam or the servo profile, so check that the machine can actually deliver the dwell the resin needs at your target speed.
● Sealing pressure — higher pressure helps HDPE because it forces the surfaces together before the film shrinks away. Too much pressure on thin LDPE thins the seal and creates a leak path.
● Cooling — HDPE and thick film need more cooling time before the bag is handled. On high-speed machines, cooling is the hidden constraint that limits output on thick film.
● Unwind tension — HDPE film is stiffer and less forgiving of tension variation; LLDPE stretches more and needs lower tension to avoid bag length drift.
Write the settings for each resin on the machine card. The most common cause of a bad shift after a material change is an operator carrying over the previous recipe.
Resin choice changes the thickness you need, which changes the cost per bag:
● Downgauging with HDPE — HDPE’s stiffness allows thinner film for the same handling feel, which is why carrier bags moved to HDPE at 12 to 18 micron. On a heavy duty bag, the limit is seal strength, not stiffness.
● LLDPE at lower thickness — higher puncture resistance sometimes allows a 10 percent thickness reduction versus LDPE at equal performance, which offsets its higher price per kilogram.
● Blends — a 70/30 LLDPE/HDPE blend is common for heavy duty liners: toughness from LLDPE, stiffness and cost from HDPE.
● The trap — specifying a cheaper resin and keeping the same thickness usually reduces performance, and specifying a thinner film in a stronger resin can reduce it too, because seal strength scales with seal area and thickness, not with tensile strength.
Calculate cost per thousand bags at the thickness that meets the load specification, not at the thickness you used last year.
A machine that runs all three resins needs five features, and it is worth confirming them before purchase:
● Temperature range and control accuracy — up to at least 300 °C with ±2 °C control, so HDPE settings are reachable without running the bar at its limit.
● Adjustable dwell — either through the servo profile or a cam change. A fixed cam machine locks you into one resin family.
● Adequate cooling — forced air or water-cooled bars. Thick HDPE at speed is a cooling problem before it is a sealing problem.
● Tension control range — wide enough for stiff HDPE and stretchy LLDPE without re-plumbing the dancer.
● Seal bar surface — Teflon or glass cloth that releases HDPE without sticking. HDPE at high temperature will cling to a worn surface and tear the seal on opening.
The FFS heavy duty bag making machine series and the CW-1400FB flying knife machine both illustrate the range question: the same frame can be specified for very different film families, but the sealing and cooling sections must be chosen for the heaviest duty you intend to run.
Practical pairings from bag-making experience:
● Construction and rubble liners — LLDPE or LLDPE-rich blends, 60 to 120 micron, because puncture resistance matters more than stiffness.
● Industrial refuse bags — HDPE/LLDPE blend, 25 to 50 micron, balancing stiffness for handling with tear resistance.
● Courier and mailing bags — coextruded LLDPE with a white or grey outer layer, 50 to 70 micron, where print surface and puncture resistance both matter.
● Heavy duty industrial sacks — thick LDPE or LLDPE, 100 to 250 micron, sealed with a wide bar. The CW-800FBA, at 0.25 mm maximum thickness, is aimed at this segment.
● Carrier bags — HDPE at 12 to 18 micron, where stiffness and cost dominate and load is modest.
Resin substitution happens, usually for cost or supply reasons. Before accepting it:
● Test the seal, not the film — a resin change can pass a tensile test and fail a peel test. Run 50 bags and peel them.
● Re-check bag length — stretchier resin drifts at the same tension setting, and a 3 mm drift over a roll is visible to the customer.
● Re-check drop performance — a bag that survives a 1.2 m drop in LDPE may split in HDPE at the same thickness, because tear resistance fell even though tensile strength rose.
● Update the paperwork — bag specification, machine card and quality plan. Substitution that is not documented becomes a dispute later.
For a deeper comparison of the resin families, see LDPE vs HDPE: similarities and differences and LDPE vs LLDPE: 10 key differences, plus the broader overview of types of polyethylene bag material.
Running more than one resin on the same line?
Send the resin grades, thicknesses and bag sizes. We will confirm the sealing and cooling range the machine needs, and give you a settings card per resin so a material change does not become a re-tuning exercise.
Yes, if the machine has an adequate temperature range, adjustable dwell, sufficient cooling and wide tension control. Machines with a fixed cam and a single sealing profile are effectively locked to one resin family.
LLDPE for puncture and impact, HDPE for tensile strength and stiffness. For bags carrying sharp or heavy content, LLDPE or an LLDPE-rich blend performs better in practice, even though HDPE shows higher tensile numbers on a data sheet.
Because HDPE film is highly oriented in the machine direction during blowing. Tear propagates easily along the orientation. LLDPE’s molecular structure resists this, which is why blends are used where snagging is likely.
Typically 150 to 180 °C on the bar, depending on thickness and machine speed, against 120 to 160 °C for LDPE. Always confirm with a peel test: a seal that tears the film is correct, one that peels open is under-sealed.
It usually costs more per kilogram, but often less per bag, because higher puncture resistance allows a thinner film at equal performance. Compare at the thickness that meets the load specification, not at equal micron.
Yes, and it is common practice. Blends are usually made at the film blowing stage, not at the bag machine, so the bag maker receives a blended film and treats it as one material with its own settings.
HDPE shrinks at seal temperature, and the shrink is asymmetric because the film is oriented. Lower the temperature, shorten the dwell and increase cooling. If curling persists, check that the seal bar is parallel and that the Teflon is not worn.
● LDPE vs HDPE: Similarities and Differences — the resin comparison in more depth.
● LDPE vs LLDPE: 10 Key Differences — processing behaviour side by side.
● Types of Polyethylene Plastic Bag Material — the wider material landscape.
Coming next: Coextruded versus Blended Film on Heavy Duty Bag Lines, and Cooling Time: The Hidden Limit on Thick Film Output.